The Sticky Topic of Halloween Candy

Ellyn Satter
October 23, 2016

The topic of Halloween candy is so sticky for parents that I address it in all of my books. Here's what I said in Your Child's Weight: Helping Without Harming Chapter 4, ''Help without harming with food selection.'' ''Treat candy the same way you do other sweets. Your child needs to learn to manage sweets and to keep sweets in proportion to the other food he eats.'' I had previously explained that treat-deprived girls in research studies load up on forbidden foods when they weren't even hungry and tend to be fatter, not thinner. Girls who were allowed treats regularly ate moderately if at all and were thinner.1

Still quoting from Your Child's Weight: ''Halloween candy presents a learning opportunity. Work toward having your child be able to manage his own stash. For him to learn, you will have to keep your interference to a minimum. When he comes home from trick or treating, let him lay out his booty, gloat over it, sort it and eat as much of it as he wants. Let him do the same the next day. Then have him put it away and relegate it to meal- and snack-time: a couple of small pieces at meals for dessert and as much as he wants for snack time.''

''If he can follow the rules, your child gets to keep control of the stash. Otherwise, you do, on the assumption that as soon as he can manage it, he gets to keep it. Offer milk with the candy, and you have a chance at good nutrition.''

Despite what most people think, studies show sugar does not affect children's behavior or cognitive performance.2 My own observation is that children who are allowed to eat sugar instead of meals and snacks provided for them by their parents are likely to show deficits in behavior and cognitive performance. That has to do with poor parenting, not poor food selection. The key phrase in my candy advice is relegate it to meal- and snack-time. Structure is key. Maintain the structure of meals and sit-down snacks, with parents retaining their leadership role in choosing the rest of the food that goes on the table. With that kind of structure and foundation, candy won't spoil a child's diet or make him too fat.

Ann Merritt, reviewer, experienced parent and pediatric dietitian, makes an observation about this important topic. ''This advice should be in every parents' magazine every year. I have seen so many kids have Halloween ruined for them when parents are over-concerned about sugar.'' When you consider that for many children, Halloween is their very favorite holiday, that is a serious concern.

Reference List

1. Birch LL, Fisher JO, Davison KK. Learning to overeat: maternal use of restrictive feeding practices promotes girls' eating in the absence of hunger. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition. 2003;78(2):215-220.

2. Wolraich ML, Wilson DB, White JW. The effect of sugar on behavior or cognition in children: A meta-analysis. Journal of the American Medical Association. 1995;274(20):1617-1621.

Originally published in 2009.  For more information, visit Ellyn Satter's Facebook page.

 

From the Parents

  • Parent # 1

    buy a suprisely online shopping

    over a year ago

  • Parent # 2

    Visit us now to obtain more details and facts regarding to

    over a year ago

  • Parent # 3

    Hi - I am really glad to discover this. great job!

    over a year ago

  • Parent # 4

    Hey guys, Im new here im sam. I hope everyone is good! I look forwards to being active here :) see you all on the forum

    over a year ago

  • Parent # 5

    While this subject can be very touchy for most people, my opinion is that there has to be a middle or common ground that we all can find. I do appreciate that youve

    over a year ago

  • Parent # 6

    Hey guys i know this might sound like a stupid question but I am seriously wondering why top end Android tablets (Viewsonic G, Notion Ink Adam) are cheaper than current mobile phones yet have much better processing power, bigger better screens and more features and can still do calls and texts. Are prices massively inflated on mobiles because the company decides that or is there any other reason? Cheers I am using iPad Epad zenithink zt-180 SourcingGate surfing the forum and your post, wow,,wow~~.

    over a year ago

  • Parent # 7

    Hey just becoming a member, glad to be in! I'm Yael and I am inspired by life, I enjoy operating and being healthy and balanced :) I've been involved in some other forums and have discovered this area to have significantly far better subject material, so it makes sense to as a final point post! BTW where is the option to change the little picture thingy like some people have, I like it but can't figure it out haha

    over a year ago

  • Parent # 8

    Hey just joining, glad to be here! I'm glad to be here as a final point, going to publish since I've been studying a extended time. I've been concerned in some other forums and have discovered this destination to have a good deal much better material, so it makes sense to finally submit! BTW, what can I do to make myself have a cool title like some people here have?

    over a year ago

  • Parent # 9

    Hey just joining, glad to be in! I'm Yael and I'm inspired by my husband, I'm a fan of running and getting nutritious :) I've been involved in some other forums and have observed this destination to have a lot greater written content, so it helps make sense to ultimately publish! BTW where is the option to change the time zone for my account? It's kind of weird having the time like 5 hours off lol

    over a year ago

  • Parent # 10

    Hey just joining, glad to be here! I'm Norma and I am inspired by my husband, I'm a fan of operating and getting nutritious :) I've been involved in some other forums and have located this destination to have significantly superior subject matter, so it makes sense to finally post! PS, how do I change the time zone for my account? It's kind of weird having the time like 5 hours off lol

    over a year ago

  • Parent # 11

    Hi, your welcome. Down anything inviting to forget about I will not, because there is no such thing, I by a hair's breadth wanted to state hello and elegantly presented. I'm so thrilled and I hand down institute my existence here was not a shame to this forum I usher in all the stress, let go b exonerate the Intimidate be with you. Thanks you for your notoriety, as well as inattention.

    over a year ago

  • Parent # 12

    The author ignores how sugar contributes to the epidemic of type II diabetes in children. Diabetes projected for 1 out of 4 born after 2000 is a actually a more serious concern than ruining Halloween. Furthermore, Halloween does not have to be ruined when other substitutes are offered instead of piles of candy. Candy mostly consists of high fructose corn syrup plus artificial colors, preservatives, and flavors--this is NOT the same as other more wholesome desserts. I think most parents can find moderation between the bad advice offered here of "[letting him] eat as much of it as he wants" and the entirely forbidding candy. Moderate choices include a reasonable limit on the number of candies or a visit from the "switch witch" or other sweet Halloween snacks with more nutrition than candy.

    over a year ago

  •  

Similar Articles

The Savvy Library

From the educational to the whimsical, our Savvy editors help you explore your world. You can search our 1977 articles by keyword, subject, or date.

Notable Selection

Below you'll find some of the more popular selections from the Savvy Library: