Go Local with a Being Savvy City Blog
May 2008
Theme: “Life is Art; Art is Life”
Welcome
The BeingSavvy blog has new posts every day, bringing you our wit and wisdom, our favorite books, toys, activities, web resources, articles -- basically, the best of our thinking as Savvy parents.
Being Savvy spotlight
Advertisement
Find Out More About
- 123s (1)
- A Day at the Beach (12)
- ABCs (2)
- Airplanes (1)
- All about Me (9)
- Anything Silly (1)
- Aquariums (1)
- Art (1)
- Art Appreciation (1)
- Autumn (3)
- Autumn Holidays (2)
- Baby Dolls (1)
- Back to School Essentials (1)
- Bathtub Games (1)
- Bedtime (1)
- Bedtime Business (1)
- Board Games (1)
- Books and Stories (10)
- Books to Make Them Wonder (3)
- Bookstores (2)
- Cars, Trucks and Things that Go (1)
- Christmas (8)
- Classic Authors (1)
- Concerts (2)
- Cooking (5)
- Dinnertime (2)
- Dressing Up (1)
- Early Reading Skills (1)
- Earth Science (1)
- Eco-Friendly (1)
- Eco-Friendly (1)
- Essential Library - Dr- Seuss (1)
- Events (2)
- Fairy Tales (1)
- Fairytales (1)
- Family (2)
- Favorite Music for the Car (4)
- Festivals (1)
- Firefighters (1)
- General Holiday (1)
- Group Games (1)
- Halloween (9)
- Hanukkah (6)
- Holidays - Halloween (1)
- Imagination (12)
- Indoor Fun (1)
- July 4th (1)
- Learning to Listen (1)
- Libraries (1)
- Life in the Big City (1)
- Making Friends (2)
- Manners (1)
- Meal Time (1)
- Memories (1)
- Monsters (1)
- Movies (1)
- Music (2)
- Music Appreciation (1)
- New Year's Day (2)
- New York City (1)
- Oh Daddy-O (1)
- Parenting (1)
- Parks and Playgrounds (1)
- Physical Activity (1)
- Pirates (2)
- Poetry for Preschoolers (2)
- Pretend Play (6)
- Princesses (1)
- Rhyming (1)
- Siblings (1)
- Splash! (Water Play) (1)
- Story Time (1)
- Storytelling (1)
- Summer (2)
- Summertime Fun (2)
- Tea Parties (1)
- Tea Party (1)
- Teachable Moments (1)
- Thanksgiving (2)
- The Beach (4)
- The Human Body (1)
- The Ocean (2)
- The Whole Wide World (1)
- The World (2)
- Theater (1)
- Trains (1)
- Transitions (1)
- Transportation (1)
- Travel Essentials (5)
- Traveling and Waiting (1)
- Water Play (2)
- Winter Holidays (10)
Savvy at the Movies: "My Kid Could Paint That"
Mon
26
2008
As fellow parents of preschoolers, we know that your movie-watching time is limited. Severely limited. Maybe some of you did manage to catch a movie over this long weekend. If so, we hope it was great. Because we just do not have time to watch bad movies anymore, do we?
Your very very high bar for movies notwithstanding, we absolutely must tell you about and urge you to see the riveting documentary "My Kid Could Paint That" (2007). Especially if you have any interest in, say, preschool-age kids. Or modern art. Or how best to nurture our children's interests and gifts. And as you know, here at Being Savvy, we're a bit obsessed with all of those things. Hence.
A quick recap: the film tells the story of Marla Olmstead, a little girl from Binghampton, New York whose paintings fetched thousands by the time she was four-years-old. She got started painting alongside her father, an amateur painter himself. A few of her paintings in a friend's coffee shop led to a gallery show, led to local press and then to a frenzy of media coverage. She was dubbed a "budding Picasso" and a "pint-sized Pollock." By her fifth birthday, she had sold more than $300,000 worth of her abstract, acrylic covered canvases. "My Kid Could Paint That" chronicles Marla's rise as a media darling, and also the backlash that occurred when "60 Minutes" aired a segment questioning the authenticity of her work. Had her father helped and directed her? Or even passed some of his own work as hers?
So the film presents something of a mystery a whodunit, so to speak. It raises provocative questions about the meaning of abstract expressionism. As a reviewer in Slate Magazine asks, "Can a work of art transcend the intentions of its maker? If a child can make great abstract paintings, does this mean that modern art is itself a hoax" And the film critically examines the role of the adults in Marla's life (her parents, her dealer, the press) and the media-hype around this supposed prodigy. The director, Amir Bar-Lev, also self-consciously acknowledges his own participation in the frenzy swirling around this small child. New York Times critic A.O. Scott argues that for this very reason, the film should never have been made.
Perhaps. But as parents of preschoolers, we're still hoping we can learn something from this story. What absorbs and makes us wonder most is Marla'a own experience, unknowable as it is. We see her playing with her baby brother. We see her getting silly in front of the camera, just as we often see our own kids doing. We see her painting, but never for all that long. We see her romping around at gallery openings. What was the good, in all of this, for her? And what was the trouble?
The trouble is fairly clear. As we've been blogging about all month, most every preschool-age child loves to make art. Art is play, and play is life, and that play often yields beautiful creations. But for Marla, it seems fair to say, art stopped being play and became, to some degree, work. And work means pressure Marla was visibly pressured to paint as expected for the cameras, and we cringed watching those scenes. As we wrote in a post on how to talk to children about their art, that kind of strain on a little one's creativity is no good for mind or soul.
Still, it's kind of wonderful to see a little girl let loose on a canvas that's bigger than she is with squirt bottles and spatulas, brushes and (of course!) her fingers. What fun! What a way to explore and learn the medium! It makes us think, why not, once in while? My kid could paint that, and so could yours and yours and yours. And then we'd have something a bit more lasting than construction paper ephemera by which to remember these fleeting years of artistic play. But, sorry, it's not for sale -- we want to keep this one for ourselves.
Your very very high bar for movies notwithstanding, we absolutely must tell you about and urge you to see the riveting documentary "My Kid Could Paint That" (2007). Especially if you have any interest in, say, preschool-age kids. Or modern art. Or how best to nurture our children's interests and gifts. And as you know, here at Being Savvy, we're a bit obsessed with all of those things. Hence.
A quick recap: the film tells the story of Marla Olmstead, a little girl from Binghampton, New York whose paintings fetched thousands by the time she was four-years-old. She got started painting alongside her father, an amateur painter himself. A few of her paintings in a friend's coffee shop led to a gallery show, led to local press and then to a frenzy of media coverage. She was dubbed a "budding Picasso" and a "pint-sized Pollock." By her fifth birthday, she had sold more than $300,000 worth of her abstract, acrylic covered canvases. "My Kid Could Paint That" chronicles Marla's rise as a media darling, and also the backlash that occurred when "60 Minutes" aired a segment questioning the authenticity of her work. Had her father helped and directed her? Or even passed some of his own work as hers?
So the film presents something of a mystery a whodunit, so to speak. It raises provocative questions about the meaning of abstract expressionism. As a reviewer in Slate Magazine asks, "Can a work of art transcend the intentions of its maker? If a child can make great abstract paintings, does this mean that modern art is itself a hoax" And the film critically examines the role of the adults in Marla's life (her parents, her dealer, the press) and the media-hype around this supposed prodigy. The director, Amir Bar-Lev, also self-consciously acknowledges his own participation in the frenzy swirling around this small child. New York Times critic A.O. Scott argues that for this very reason, the film should never have been made.
Perhaps. But as parents of preschoolers, we're still hoping we can learn something from this story. What absorbs and makes us wonder most is Marla'a own experience, unknowable as it is. We see her playing with her baby brother. We see her getting silly in front of the camera, just as we often see our own kids doing. We see her painting, but never for all that long. We see her romping around at gallery openings. What was the good, in all of this, for her? And what was the trouble?
The trouble is fairly clear. As we've been blogging about all month, most every preschool-age child loves to make art. Art is play, and play is life, and that play often yields beautiful creations. But for Marla, it seems fair to say, art stopped being play and became, to some degree, work. And work means pressure Marla was visibly pressured to paint as expected for the cameras, and we cringed watching those scenes. As we wrote in a post on how to talk to children about their art, that kind of strain on a little one's creativity is no good for mind or soul.
Still, it's kind of wonderful to see a little girl let loose on a canvas that's bigger than she is with squirt bottles and spatulas, brushes and (of course!) her fingers. What fun! What a way to explore and learn the medium! It makes us think, why not, once in while? My kid could paint that, and so could yours and yours and yours. And then we'd have something a bit more lasting than construction paper ephemera by which to remember these fleeting years of artistic play. But, sorry, it's not for sale -- we want to keep this one for ourselves.
Comments
05.08_jewelry_lc_map5;1;2
Immediately I have to think of you and really, it was a story about you,
well sort of,
We have a page for marshalling in which we will be putting information on what is involved in marshalling and how people will be able to volunteer and train,
It really gives me a great feeling to see people who really care. ,
Already a Member? Please Log In
Before we can add your comments, you must be logged in.
Not a Savvy Parent Yet?
We would love for you to join The Savvy Source community.
By joining you can bookmark your favorite preschools as well as review and comment on schools. You will also receive our newsletters chock full of expert tips on educational toys, tools and books to help your toddler and preschooler flourish.
Note that we respect your privacy and do not share any information with third parties.
about the savvy
source for parents
The savviest ideas and inspiration on how best to help our children learn and grow.
 |
 |
| Preschools | Activities |
Advertisement
Humming? Strumming? What is your child doing musically?
- 51% of 3 year olds can clap to a given rhythm
- 18% of 2 year olds can sing basic repetitive songs
- 36% of 4 year olds can shake maracas to a beat
Find out more about what your child can do!
Review Your Preschool
Join the hundreds of parents helping other parents find the right preschool for their child.
View Preschools and Daycare Centers in Other Cities
View preschools and daycare centers in other cities